Our Blogs
Is it illegal to clip coins?
Picture of Joshua White
Joshua White

Clipped Planchet Error Coins
Clipped Planchet Error Coins

I first noticed clipped coins when a collector showed me a George Washington quarter with suspiciously smooth edges. The damaged coin sparked my curiosity - why would anyone alter currency this way? Let's explore the legal and historical aspects of coin mutilation.

Coin clipping refers to illegally shaving precious metals from coin edges. In the United States, Title 18 Section 331 of U.S. Code explicitly prohibits defacing coins with penalties up to $10,000 fine and 5 years imprisonment.

This practice isn't just modern vandalism. Let me walk you through its surprisingly royal origins and why those ridges on your coins matter more than you think.

Why is coin clipping1 bad?

Coin clipping destroys historical value and economic trust. When I inspected a 1792 half disme for a client, the missing silver content from edge shaving reduced its value by 87%.

Clipping coins reduces metal content, destabilizes currency systems, and enables counterfeiting. Modern reeded edges2 act as both security feature and historical safeguard against precious metal theft.

3 key impacts of coin clipping:

  1. Economic Impact
    Reduces actual value vs face value
  2. Collector Impact
    Makes authentication difficult
  3. Legal Impact
    Triggers felony charges in most countries
Clipping Method Detection Difficulty Typical Coin Targets
Manual Filing Moderate Silver dollars
Machine Milling High Gold bullion coins
Chemical Erosion Extreme Ancient coins

Who invented coin edges?

The solution came from England's Royal Mint. While examining Isaac Newton's mint records (yes, that Newton), I discovered his 1696 memo about "ridged crowns to foil clippers."

Sir Isaac Newton introduced reeded edges as Master of the Mint in 1696. This innovation combined security and practicality - ridges made clipping detectable while improving coin stacking.

Edge evolution timeline:

  • Ancient Coins (pre-1500): Plain edges
  • Spanish Milled Dollars (1732): Crude markings
  • Newton's Great Recoinage (1696): Standardized reeding
  • Modern Security Edges (2000s): Laser-engraved patterns

What does the D stand for on a penny?

The mint mark mystery unraveled during my visit to Denver Mint. That tiny "D" represents more than location - it's quality assurance in miniature.

The D on pennies indicates Denver Mint production. Since 1906, this mark guarantees specific silver content ratios and minting standards unique to this facility.

Mint mark meanings:

Mark Location Specialization
D Denver Circulating coins
S San Francisco Proof/collector coins
W West Point Bullion/commemoratives
P Philadelphia Experimental alloys

How to tell if a coin is uncirculated?

Last month, a client nearly bought a "mint condition" 1921 Morgan dollar until we spotted micro-scratches. Here's how to avoid such mistakes.

Uncirculated coins show zero wear marks, full mint luster, and sharp edge details. Use 10x magnification to check for bag marks or contact scratches.

Circulated vs. Uncirculated Checklist

Feature Circulated Uncirculated
Surface Dull patina Mirror-like finish
Edge Reeding Worn down Crisp ridges
High Points Flatness Raised details
Field Marks Scratches present Clean fields

Professional-Grade Coins for Serious Collectors

At INIMAKER, we've produced museum-grade replicas for the British Museum and durable commemoratives for the Paris Olympics. Our ISO 9001-certified facility combines historical accuracy with modern security features:

Authentic Finishes

  • 18K gold plating meeting ASTM B-488 standards
  • Historical patina recreation technology

Anti-Fraud Features

  • Micro-engraved serial numbers
  • RFID tracking chips

Fast Turnaround

  • 15-day standard production
  • DHL/FedEx tracked shipping

Whether you're creating educational sets showing coin evolution or limited collector editions, our 12+ years of metal craftsmanship ensures every detail matters. Contact our team for free 3D proofs.

Conclusion

Coin preservation protects both monetary value and human history. From Newton's reeded edges to modern laser markings, each security feature tells a story of economic innovation. Always verify mint marks and surface conditions when assessing coin authenticity.



  1. Understanding the legal ramifications of coin clipping can help collectors and investors protect their assets and avoid penalties. 

  2. Learning about the purpose of reeded edges can enhance your understanding of coin security features and their historical significance. 

We are at your disposal for any technical or commercial information

A professional will contact you within 24 hours

Please check your email